The reason for account inspection upon first glance is to screen for trolling on the first level. The second would be to check their posts and logic viability. The third and last is to actually run with them and allow them the freedom to prove themselves.
Sounds about right and fair, no?
Account inspection is just a generalization. Are you going to claim that everyone that has 3 Paragon 100 characters has more knowledge about how the game should be than people that don't?
The only thing that should matter is what they say and the logic presented to back it up. For example:
10/16/2013 06:32 PMPosted by ZRaiyneLet me ask you, if you are buying a house would you ask a car salesman to give you a rough idea about what the good deals are? If your answer is yes, then read no further. rofl.
If he's going to tell me which houses are good deals, I will certainly ask him why he thinks that way. If the logic he presents seems legitimate, I will absolutely at least consider the houses he suggested.
Again, there is nothing flawed about this logic. It is plain common sense to check credibility, especially from those that claim experience in a game like this.
Checking credibility is a simple shortcut in life. Are you going to blindly follow what a real estate agent says about which houses are good deals? I can admit that it's better than blindly following what a care salesman says, but you really need to think about what either of them says. When you're trying to throw credibility as the only measurement of how legitimate a person's views are, you're basically saying that you simply don't have the intelligence to think for yourself on the subject.
In other words, you can look his account and say that he probably doesn't know what he's talking about. It's only a generalization, and it doesn't necessarily mean he certainly doesn't know what he's talking about like you're saying. If everything the OP said had bad or no logic following it up, then I wouldn't even bother to post in this thread. The OP gave his point of view with a very detailed explanation of why he feels that way.
I wouldn't care if the OP never played a character past lvl30. His logic is solid and his views are very agreeable. If you can't think of actual counter-logic to disprove him, then I have nothing else to say to you.