Oh boy... Mine's actually quite funny. I grew up watching the Alien trilogy because my uncle (who was my caretaker at the time) thought it was appropriate for a 4 year old. So I wasn't really scared by movies.
I had my first nightmare after going to Universal Studios and meeting the Ninja Turtles in person.
For some odd reason I have yet to grasp those things just traumatized me.
Hahaha that is gold, my Dad was the same he use to own a video store so he'd let me get out whatever i wanted, horrors had the coolest covers so thats what i would always get. Watching childs play then having to sleep at my Grandma's in a room full of creepy dolls wasn't the best of ideas...