Tichondrius PvE Guilds and Progression

Tichondrius
Prev 1 8 9 10 18 Next
07/01/2011 10:50 PMPosted by Kategosselin


What? Your statement makes no sense. If you don't see the point of comparing the two types of guilds, then there should be no separation.


Organizing twelve people versus 30 against content that is undertuned against the former is incomparable. Look at how many ten man guilds there are now versus 25. 25 man raiding is nearly dead like everyone expected when this raid model was proposed prior to Cataclysm. If tens aren't overtuned there is no reason to raid 25 simply due to logistics.


Logistically, yea 25s can be somwhat harder. But 25s also gear much much faster, so it makes the encounters easier faster than in 10m. Also in blizz's eyes, there is no difference, which is why the achievements/server firsts are blind to what size raid completed them.


Organizing twelve people versus 30 against content that is undertuned against the former is incomparable. Look at how many ten man guilds there are now versus 25. 25 man raiding is nearly dead like everyone expected when this raid model was proposed prior to Cataclysm. If tens aren't overtuned there is no reason to raid 25 simply due to logistics.


Logistically, yea 25s can be somwhat harder. But 25s also gear much much faster, so it makes the encounters easier faster than in 10m. Also in blizz's eyes, there is no difference, which is why the achievements/server firsts are blind to what size raid completed them.


Not only that in 10m you have to have everyone play perfect. It's less forgiving if someone screws up than a 25m.
Leave this discussion for another thread please. There is a clear separation between 10 and 25 man (as you guys even proved further with your comments) and that distinction will remain in the rankings.
The point of gallowglass's and my post is that both sizes have disadvantages and advantages, so it's a fairly leveling playing field. Our comments don't further prove that there should be a separation at all.
There at least should be an overall ranking. Since quite a few guilds on this server claim to be 25 and then go for kills on 10.


The Vindictive (10 man guild) downed Shannox, Beth'tilac, Alysrazor and Lord Rhyolith.
Invidious is 4/7 10man, my armory works for dates
updated
Slack 25 shannox and beth down last week. I missed shannox but check others's achevabmesnt
heroic shannox down! vid incoming!
slack 25 man leg boss down

Edit:
Goldar from the original power rangers down
(Baelroc)
crackers and rice is 5/7
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=foS4Z-5OynU
heroic overtuned son of a gun rock boss


vid incoming
Are You Done - 7/7.
Poor Decisions dropped Alysrazor (25m).
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Uj9QFiy1S8
updated
The Vindictive (10 man) is now 6/7.
HEROIC OVERTUNEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD HEADBASHING BETH DOWWN

Join the Conversation

Return to Forum