Why are the wintraders getting to keep gear?

Battlegrounds
I'm glad you finally decided to crack down on win traders but why in the world are you letting them keep their T2 gear they cheated to obtain? If I'm a wintrader (and I'm not, but if I was), I would gladly take a 72 hour ban in exchange for full elite gear and a T2 weapon...

You're basically saying, "we know you cheated, but we're going to let you keep what you cheated to obtain..."
Revenue.
01/30/2013 06:56 AMPosted by Wyler
Revenue.
So basically we can all Win trade get our elite gear and take a 3 day ban?
01/30/2013 11:13 AMPosted by Paníc
So basically we can all Win trade get our elite gear and take a 3 day ban?


looks like it :(

Who knows, maybe they will do something else as well once they do more investigating. I hope.
01/30/2013 11:17 AMPosted by Zeroizer
So basically we can all Win trade get our elite gear and take a 3 day ban?


looks like it :(

Who knows, maybe they will do something else as well once they do more investigating. I hope.


I think they will be pushing some perm bans after that three days.
3 Days break, reset RBG rating and you get to keep your GEAR ... hey no wonder pvp is so screwed !
01/30/2013 11:19 AMPosted by Skul


looks like it :(

Who knows, maybe they will do something else as well once they do more investigating. I hope.


I think they will be pushing some perm bans after that three days.


That's awesome. Get T2 for the rest of the season and then play GW2 or something else for a couple day break then get to stomp rest of season in T2 gear. Not bad at all tbh.
So, after looking at the ladder, I see a lot still with gear and their ratings intact.....so if the ban wave has ended, HIRE Blizz cause you didn't get the ban wave right.
damn my 3.3k is gone
good thing everything my 3.3k got me still exists!

damnit blizzard
no more half measures
Dear Blizzard:

Please send me a complete set of the top-end PvP gear, and I promise to not log on for a WHOLE WEEK.

Affectionately yours,

Mistwidget

P.S. Would it be too much to have you enchant and gem it for me too? Please? I'll stay off for an EXTRA week.

EDIT: sorry, could not resist, even though I don't have a dog in this fight lol :P
It's Day 1. Let's see what happens in a week or two.

Also, revenue is just silly. Stahp. "Why don't they stop botters?" - Revenue! "Why don't they take gear away?" - Revenue! "Why are healing priest bad?" - Revenue! "Who likes cheese?" - Revenue!

While I agree that they should lose their gear, ranks, etc., who knows what is still in the works? I don't. Do you?

Finally, the gear will be obsolete soon enough anyways. I won't lose any sleep over them keeping the gear as long as they don't keep the mounts/titles/achieves.
It's Day 1. Let's see what happens in a week or two.

Also, revenue is just silly. Stahp. "Why don't they stop botters?" - Revenue! "Why don't they take gear away?" - Revenue! "Why are healing priest bad?" - Revenue! "Who likes cheese?" - Revenue!

While I agree that they should lose their gear, ranks, etc., who knows what is still in the works? I don't. Do you?

Finally, the gear will be obsolete soon enough anyways. I won't lose any sleep over them keeping the gear as long as they don't keep the mounts/titles/achieves.


Wisdom.

We don't know what is going to happen. There's a lot of people saying they were banned by mistake, or unfairly. Perhaps this is the first of a multi-step solution.
01/30/2013 12:51 PMPosted by Eisenhorne
Finally, the gear will be obsolete soon enough anyways


REVENUE!
A lot of people at 2400+ got banned. Teams who play legit at 2400 had 80% of their players banned because they faced some wintraders throughout the season.

This is the biggest joke ever. We play 5-10hours everyday in rbgs and quee into other 2300+ teams on my main acocunt and destroy them. Most of us are gladiators or multi-gladiators and a lot of our games are streamed with multi 1000's of viewers - yet we all get banned.

Heck, just the day before we got banned we played 6 hours and went 17-2 v all 2300+ teams.

Where is the logic in that!?
01/30/2013 01:23 PMPosted by Dórá
Where is the logic in that!?


If a large enough proportion of ratings are invalid (due to win trading or whatever), and if ratings are used to measure skill or achievement, those who played to their high rating through honest means will have been matched up with players that they shouldn't have.

So if 1 of every 5 teams you play and beat have an artificially high rating, your own rating is too high by about 20%.

I don't know if there is a way to fix things while being fair to everybody.

You shouldn't be mad at Blizzard, you should be mad at the people who jacked up the rating system so badly.

(edit: That's as complicated as I'm willing to make math on the forums. Please don't take it as a well-researched example, I just pulled numbers out of the air.)
Finally, the gear will be obsolete soon enough anyways


REVENUE!


SCREEN SHOTS OR IT DIDN'T HAPPEN!!!!

I will SO drop a train on your house. >.>
The whole purpose for win trading WAS the gear. Now that they have it, stripping them of "rating" isn't going to do jack.

:(
I plan on wintrading next season, to bust out a huge rating in the first week or two and then get mad conquest every week.

Blizzard has proven there's no punishment for me to fear.
01/30/2013 11:44 AMPosted by Chammie
3 Days break, reset RBG rating and you get to keep your GEAR ... hey no wonder pvp is so screwed !


I doubt it's over. We could very well see the gear removed and some perm bans given out.

Join the Conversation

Return to Forum