1) New ladder players of GOD KNOWS WHAT SKILL get pitted against Bronze players, messing up our wins. Ladder players should be placed against only ladder players. And if they have a trouble finding an opponent add Gold players. More trouble? Then add silver and platinum, but NEVER allow match ups with Bronze.
2) You have players deranking themselves into Bronze, again, of GOD KNOWS WHAT skill level. If any player in Gold or above wins a game in their league - not counting funky ladder placements - they should never, EVER be allowed to derank into Bronze! Let them derank to Silver 100 and that's it!
3) For the last few weeks or more, I've been tracking the top 15 names in my league to see if anyone gets out of the Bronze prison. NO ONE is getting out. They're all still there. I have hope for a couple of them right now. Glorious just launched himself from Bronze 9 to Bronze 1 with only 72 wins compared to my 131. JohnnyT is at Bronze 4 with only 48 wins, and a 14-game streak recently. I wish he would play more so I could see proof that people leave the league. So these people are better then me and they're not getting out.
4) As a Bronze, I've been placed against GOLD PLAYERS! I don't care how MMR works. This is broken. You should never face a player that is two leagues above you. Yes, I won ONCE, but all the losses from Gold and top 25 silver players are not helping my plight. I don't mind playing harder players, but two leagues above you is way too extreme.
Do you know who I lose against a lot? Bronze 1-3's. Do you know why? Because they are good, and they, like me, DON'T BELONG in Bronze league either. This is clear indication that top 3 bronzes are stuck and the system is broken.
I hardly ever face top 100 silvers, but I beat them handily. I face top 50 silvers, and I beat them over 60% of the time. I lose against top 25 silvers most of the time. Can you guess where I really belong? Silver top 50. That's where most all Bronze top 3's belong in this broken system.
I've heard the nightmares in many threads. "I've been stuck in bronze for 3 to 5 seasons", or "I'm a platinum player and I tried to help my bronze friend get out of the league, and after 120 wins.... I was finally able to do it"?!?!? "I'm finally now a silver player and I can't believe these people are here and how easy they are to beat."
I read proof, after proof, after proof of how the system is broken.