Just for note, I queued at level 17 and did not have Exorcism yet.
My rotation with Righteous Fury on was Avengers Shield for pull, Judge, Crusader Strike, then Judge when it came off CD, then AS and Crusader Strike when I could....I felt like 80% of my attacks were white attacks.
I would run in throw my shield and immediately see the words, "Losing Threat." Maybe that was speedy DPS's fault for not letting me build any threat.
Pretty much mobs would 2.5 shot me...if the healer wasn't basically god, I was dead...no one else died either just me. And yes the healer was ready when I pulled.
So my question is what am I doing wrong...besides well it feels like everything.
I'm actually pretty frustrated because pre-4.0; I had a DK tank and Prot Warrior tank and they were really easy for me, but this just yea it's not.