Prot Paladin Gemming
It depends on the socket bonus imo.
Parry and Dodge should be kept about even and Mastery should be prioritized as well. Stamina seems to be a lot less important than in WotLK but still fairly important.
I'd go with Sta>Mastery (that will set you up 1 whole mastery point or close enough to where new gear will get you there) > parry = dodge > hit > expertise
I don't think hit and expertise shouldn't be our priorities until real raids perhaps ----mitigation is quite important right now.
your expertise is 9. your hit is 2.87%. your evasion % is 55% (cap is 102%)
according to that guide your #1 priority should be gettign the prime glyph for seal of truth for +10 expertise. then get 7 more expertise from gear (for the minimum 26). after that work your hit as much as possible until you're comfortable with the % (should be 4-6% at least). at that point increase your evasion would make sense, but mastery is generally seen as better than dodge.
In your case especially, your dodge is at 14.65% and your parry is 10.72% which means that you should be picking parry over dodge in order to maximize your gain. But I wouldn't worry about that until your exp/hit is acceptable.
Please report any Code of Conduct violations, including:
Threats of violence. We take these seriously and will alert the proper authorities.
Posts containing personal information about other players. This includes physical addresses, e-mail addresses, phone numbers, and inappropriate photos and/or videos.
Harassing or discriminatory language. This will not be tolerated.