Warrior/DK Threat is broken

100 Draenei Shaman
5060
Actually, I think part of my particular problem is that paladin threat generation feels very low. I have less problems with warriors and almost none with bears or DKs. Sadly something like 90% of LFD tanks seem to be paladins. Of course as DPS gear scales up tank threat will drop proportionally, and vengeance doesn't have time to stack in 5mans.

But (again) that's not the point of this thread-- the point is that in a world where threat really, really matters, being one of two classes without any way to manage your threat puts you at a severe disadvantage.

All I'm asking for here is a copy of wind shear, people.
Edited by Slant on 12/27/2010 1:58 PM PST
Reply Quote
17 Troll Warrior
100
12/27/2010 1:37 PMPosted by Slant
You people are attacking a straw man. I never said that DKs and warriors should be able to ignore threat. Do rogues, ferals, enhance shamans, etc, ignore their threat? No. They have buttons to press to manage it. There's gameplay there.


Those classes also do not have the front loaded damage of DK's or Warriors. It is the way DK's and Warriors do damage that gets bad players into trouble. They simply do not realize so much of their damage comes in such a short window and they can unload it right at the start of the pull. Not knowing that gets them into trouble.

Rogues, Ferals and Enhance have more ramp up time than Warriors and DK's in PvE. Yes, they have some threat dumps, but that isn't what is keeping them below the tank on the pull. They just simply set up their rotation and they are pacing themselves.

Another "you people"... You people talk about your tanks having no problems. Yes, your warrior friend has no problems, because he's a good player, properly specced and geared. Try a LFD PUG sometime. LFD is where this stuff gets real, folks.


You should not expect a PuG to play like a seasoned raider because chances are they are not. You have a level of expectation that does not have a place in LFD. You might run into a long time tank like myself (I have been tanking and dps'ing since Luci in MC), but that will be rare. You should expect mediocre at best players in a PuG especially when the content is as new as it is now.

"You people" number 3-- You people keep talking about howling blast. Please re-read the original post. I out-threat tanks single-target. I pull aggro off bosses. Please stop talking about hitting howling blast early on groups. Everybody understands that's bad. Warriors don't have howling blast, and they have threat issues too.


I have already explained most of Warriors' threat problems. It is too much front loaded damage without the self-control to not hit Death Wish.
Reply Quote
100 Draenei Shaman
5060
Who's talking about "on the pull"? Who's talking about "front loaded" and "ramp up"? Not me, that's for sure.

Re-read the OP, please.
Edited by Slant on 12/27/2010 2:08 PM PST
Reply Quote
73 Orc Warlock
960
you do not need a threat dump.

play smarter, or get a soul stone.
Reply Quote
17 Troll Warrior
100
12/27/2010 1:48 PMPosted by Slant
So you seriously haven't read the thread at all, then? Please re-read the OP then get back to us.

This thread is about active threat management, which everybody but DKs and warriors has.


I have been reading the thread. I think you simply don't understand that how you do damage is just as important as how much you do.

Warrior do not need any threat management abilities. Good warriors do not have threat problems when they are playing with an equally geared and skilled tank. This is because they know they have front loaded damage, and thus front loaded threat. By simply not hitting Death Wish or Deadly Calm and unloading the full rotation at the start of the pull they do not have any problems with threat barring any mob avoided or missed tank abilities very early in the pull.
Reply Quote
17 Troll Warrior
100
12/27/2010 2:06 PMPosted by Slant
Who's talking about "on the pull"? Who's talking about "front loaded" and "ramp up"? Not me, that's for sure.

Re-read the OP, please.


I have read the OP.

You are talking about "waiting" and still pulling aggro in a PuG. You are playing a class that has a ton of front loaded damage with little ramp up time. Even waiting might not be enough with a tank that is less skilled than you. This is simply because how you do your damage based on your class mechanics.

You keep talking about Warriors and DK's needing threat management abilities beyond simply knowing how the class works and acting appropriately. It isn't some magical coincidence that the two melee classes with similar burst damage profiles are running into threat problems even after waiting. You can make up a ton of ground in terms of threat in a short period of time even after waiting. This is because of the way you do damage. The good warriors and DK's understand this, pace themselves better than most people and don't have threat problems while they have a similarly geared and skilled tank.
Reply Quote
85 Human Warrior
4485
ITT: Awful tanks.

I have no issues with threat management, whether it be snap threat at the start or long-term on boss encounters.
Reply Quote
85 Worgen Death Knight
6570
If tanks are losing aggro, it's not because of some need for dps threat dumps. It's because that tank is BAD. Vengeance is borderline broken for how much threat it gives.
Reply Quote
100 Draenei Shaman
5060
12/27/2010 2:32 PMPosted by Jathine
You are talking about "waiting" and still pulling aggro in a PuG. You are playing a class that has a ton of front loaded damage with little ramp up time. Even waiting might not be enough with a tank that is less skilled than you. This is simply because how you do your damage based on your class mechanics.

I disagree with what you're saying, but lets just say for a minute you're right.

Even if you're right DKs and warriors remain screwed, and this should be addressed in some other way than "get better tanks lol". I know guild groups are better, thanks very much. LFD PUGs are a huge part of the game now, and ignoring them is not productive.
Edited by Slant on 12/27/2010 3:16 PM PST
Reply Quote
85 Human Warrior
4485
12/27/2010 3:15 PMPosted by Slant
You are talking about "waiting" and still pulling aggro in a PuG. You are playing a class that has a ton of front loaded damage with little ramp up time. Even waiting might not be enough with a tank that is less skilled than you. This is simply because how you do your damage based on your class mechanics.

I disagree with what you're saying, but lets just say for a minute you're right.

Even if you're right DKs and warriors remain screwed, and this should be addressed in some other way than "get better tanks lol". I know guild groups are better, thanks very much. LFD PUGs are a huge part of the game now, and ignoring them is not productive.


No, the issue here is that LFD pugs in general need to "Get better."

Don't make the game easier just because 100% of people aren't able to play good enough to hold threat.
Reply Quote
85 Troll Death Knight
8085
12/27/2010 1:48 PMPosted by Slant
This thread is about active threat management, which everybody but DKs and warriors has.

Not really.

Pures have the good aggro drops, generally. Feign Death, Vanish, Invisibility, Soul Shatter.

Pretty much everyone else either has a very weak aggro drop or doesn't have one at all.
Reply Quote
100 Draenei Shaman
5060
No.

Wind shear is 5% total threat now, it's great, so shamans are covered. Druids have 10% with cower, so they're more than fine. Paladins have 20% with hand of salv, so they're A-OK. It's just DKs and warriors that entirely lack threat management.

Pure aggro drops are certainly better, don't get me wrong, but of the hybrids only DKs and warriors lack them entirely.
Reply Quote

Please report any Code of Conduct violations, including:

Threats of violence. We take these seriously and will alert the proper authorities.

Posts containing personal information about other players. This includes physical addresses, e-mail addresses, phone numbers, and inappropriate photos and/or videos.

Harassing or discriminatory language. This will not be tolerated.

Forums Code of Conduct

Report Post # written by

Reason
Explain (256 characters max)
Submit Cancel

Reported!

[Close]