Attempting to fix the issue, I had tried relogging, logging over to another toon and logging back, exiting the game completely and logging back in, swapping specs/gear, porting back and forth from Org; nothing really seems to fix the issues 100% consistently.
I have uploaded a combat log of a recent Bear run. My gear is a mix of tank and cat gear. With an unbugged rip, I notice 6-8k non-crit ticks, and 14-18k crits (5pt Rips, obviously). In this log, you can clearly see 2.5k non-crits, and 4-5k crits.