I will say that I'm not one to take someone's word alone to prove their innocence, but I'm also not going to throw him under the bus because other people say to. I'd like to see some proof, mostly to put all this drama aside, but what he does is his business.
As for guardian heroes' support, if they have the proof that they need to feel that he isn't botting, just excessively farming, then kudos to them for standing up for their guildie. I would like to know what said proof is, but again, if you have it you don't have to share.
And Meep, <3 I love me a good public /gkicking. Better than the gold Rugburnhurts isn't making. :P
Vhex, I think you had a good idea in trying to call out the problem. I also think you got a little butthurt and went off in a bad way. Good luck with your guild search!