Im sure if any guild was in the same circumstance they wouldnt of called the raid, Sud was there for the whole raid and he didnt change specs for Hagaraa he was always ret.
The proof is in our logs. I dont get why people keep trying to say otherwise, the proof is there not hidden from anyone, our logs are always live. (Also a video of the kill)
I dont get why so many people are having a sook and making things up about this, it doesnt change anything progression wise. If you dont count our first kill thats ok, we still have downed it again (8/2/12 for 2nd kill) and are still 5/8.
No guild would have called their raid and im sure you deserve credit when you killed the boss without the ret bug but also dont forget that even though you knew about the bug you immediately rushed on the forums here to post your kill =D