The purpose of this thread is to discuss whether or not you believe Will of Unbinding is best in slot for the atonement healing, described in the forum thread I linked originally, and/or how it could be fixed to allow us access to it in LFR. Here is the item I discuss:
First let me start by saying that I believe this trinket is the bomb. It's "proc" literally provides the intellect of nearly two "static" trinkets from the same raid level and it isn't difficult to juggle the stacks as atonement if you're Smiting at least once between your HF cool down and casting HF off cool down. (more on how the HF and Smiting is used, again, should be discussed in the forum topic at the beginning of this thread)
I believe the solution for blizzard's item stealing complication could easily be solved by forcing the roll bonus to be provided by talents at the time of the encounter. essentially snapshotting specs & glyphs during combat (so they can't be alterred) and basing the "Role bonus" off that. So a disc priest couldn't get the Will of unbinding unless he/she had the "Atonement" talent AND the "Glyph of Divine Accuracy"
Perhaps if that were too difficult to implement, a wish-list system could be implemented that is auto verified by the Role bonus system with a few modifications. (So wo don't miss out on our BiS trinket for example) then the current system, that checks for roll in the raid, would instead check for if it's on their wish list: "Yes it is...ok here is your +100!"
What do you think guys? Any ideas on either of these topics?