I don't know if I would go that far. Pts for/against suggest at least some consistency. I think the boat finally "sank" when McNabb left. I am not saying he is some offensive messiah (I hated him in washington... equally as much as I did in Philly), but he worked well in their system. Give him a Dean Pees protege, and about 5yrs to rework the defense... and he will be barely scraping the wild card just as soon as the chiefs throw him some draft money. But don't expect another DeShawn/McNabb combo from him EVER... that was his one-trick pony.