New Tank Time!

85 Night Elf Warrior
Yes, but you can't seriously say it's complex. And it's still boring but that's just my bitterness from playing a warrior since Vanilla, when threat mattered... But also... it's pre-xpac. Things will change by the time we're into the first tier raid content.

I guess my point to the OP, is right now is NOT the time to decide on a new tanking class, pre-xpac is always tuned for the max level of that xpac, thus the month before, is always hectic, full of OP classes, and seriously nerf bat mugging classes.
Reply Quote
90 Tauren Warrior
09/08/2012 02:09 AMPosted by Sliphe
I haven't really found my warrior that difficult to play. A bit clunky, yes, but certainly not difficult. Where is this idea that warriors are complex to play coming from?

Traditionally, warriors tend to have more tools than the other tanks. We've always been very re-active as tanks, a different tool for every situation.

Unfortunately, that's no longer the case. Blizzard, in their infinite wisdom, made us more active by limiting the number of tools we have, and forcing us to watch the pretty red rage bar.
Reply Quote
90 Tauren Warrior
if you just push your buttons when you have rage for anything but trash i feel your probably not going to fare well come mop. The problem with warrior tanking for me is the clunky feel of the rage pool and then oh look he's going to hit me hard ill press a button now. Maybe ill get more comfortable with it in time but i'm definitely going to try a couple of other tanking classes now.

And as for pally tanking, our pally tank is re-rolling a mage for mop
Reply Quote
90 Human Paladin

I have an answer for that...

You start off at 20k mana, and as you use it, you replenish it, but the fact is, it is better to be at 20k mana than 0 mana.

For a warrior or druid, it is the reverse. You have 0 rage, and have to build it up.

A dk is different than all of them.

It possesses a rage system, probably very much like the one now adopted for warriors and druids, but it also has a rune system. It can be rather confusing to use both of these systems at first, but as you catch on, you realize it is not as difficult to use as rage, because you still have resources ready at the pull.

Dk's rune and RP resource system is different then most other classes system, but it's not if you look at it the way it actually works out.

not many abilities require RP _AND_ runes. So if you know which abilities you have to pool RP for, and which abilities you have to pool runes for (and which runes, and which abilities you can use to regain those runes quickly) it's not really that hard of a system to adapt to.

Mind you I've never had any more of an issue with my DK vs. my paladin but i don't raid tank on my DK. I mostly just leave it to 5 mans. But i still play it the same way, I might only use the DK for 5 man tanking but I'm not one of those scrubs who runs with no gems and enchants ^__^

I think you missed the point. Rage is a resource that warriors and bears have 0 of at the start of a fight, correct? Aside of popped abilities, orleft over from the fight before, it will also decay over time. Mana does not, we can agree on that, correct?

A DK has a rage similar ability. Probably more similar now, than it was. Runic power was generated as we hit things or when we used certain abilities. It also starts out at 0 and decays over time not in combat, the exact same way a bear or a warrior tank does, correct? OK, so, if DK's didn't have runes, the 3 tanks would be incredibly similar, and have to start rage regeneration at the pull, but DK's have 6 runes, also. These refresh, in that sense, similar to mana, but entirely different. And it is also way different from holy power, too. DK's do not start a fight without any resources the same way a warrior or a bear does, they have 6 runes, while pallies have 20k mana.

It really doesn't matter that no DK ability requires both runes and runic at the same time, the point I made was, runes regenerate, not decay.
Reply Quote
90 Human Paladin
Unless we have a fight like Vezax which cripples Ret and Prot now since Judgements of the Bold/Wise no longer exist in game, I could disable my mana bar on my Shadowed Unit Frames and it still wouldn't make a difference for me because I'm limited by my Holy Power generation, not my mana.
Edited by Sliphe on 9/10/2012 3:02 PM PDT
Reply Quote

Please report any Code of Conduct violations, including:

Threats of violence. We take these seriously and will alert the proper authorities.

Posts containing personal information about other players. This includes physical addresses, e-mail addresses, phone numbers, and inappropriate photos and/or videos.

Harassing or discriminatory language. This will not be tolerated.

Forums Code of Conduct

Report Post # written by

Explain (256 characters max)