09/20/2012 06:23 PMPosted by Drailen
Yep, made a mistake. Terrible!
But seriously, go write books yourself if you can instantly say when a book is bad and when it isn't.
Oh I definitely know there are issues with prose that are more difficult to tackle in reality than in egotistical imagination.
However, one does not need to be a published writer to know bad writing. To suggest any critic needs to be is a fallacious argument: a critic is a representative of the reader, not the writer.
Ok. Ill just forget that writing mistake commentary cause that's just you being stupid.
Now, I understand you don't need to be a writer to critic a book. But saying everyone who enjoy said book is stupid is what sounded stupid in your post.