We understand that attempting to pvp flag us is fair game.
Yea, the discussion started because we stole a boss kill from Dunder Mifflin after they had tagged it by taunting it until it leashed and despawned. We also flagged and when some of them hit us they became flagged.
We don't want to come across as jerks and bullies, but many of our members really enjoy the thrill and competition that comes from fighting tooth and nail for these kills. It was fun to have a guild wide call to arms, with everybody converging, jumping in raid, summoning, etc.
Anyway, Orangemoon, our GM, thought it was fair to let people know what our policy was and see what other people on the server thought.
A quote from them stating they had taunt despawned Galleon, from this thread http://us.battle.net/wow/en/forum/topic/6759326872
This kinda falls under the same stuff that happened with people were making 1 lvls to die and make Kazzak regen health. So hopefully something will happen.