I just had one of *those* guild groups; Scarlet Halls.
3/5 guild group, Monk, Dk tank, Pally; me and Mage were pugs.
Right off the bat I notice the tank is having threat issues....as in, I get healing aggro, and it takes him FOREVER to peel off me. Doing the archer gauntlet, I am keeping LB up like I always do, tank gets to the end, drops the shield, and all of the mobs beeline for me with the tank chasing after them. He peels 1-2, and the DPS each get one until the monk does SCK, gets them all, and becomes to defacto tank for the rest of the fight.
First boss goes down ok, and the next few rooms were near chaos; I had aggro for almost every pull...lovely.
Then we get to Harlan; first adds, I am up near the door, they beeline for me, I jump down, tank runs up the Opposite stair and just misses the adds on me, all while the boss is hitting him in the back. Then on the first blades of light everyone but me gets caught in it, and there is no way in hell Tranq can heal them; its a wipe, so I just stop.
Second attempt, same thing, adds beating on me, retadin and mage get caught in blades again, both die. BR the mage, who then dies to the next baldes. By this point ,I have 5-6 adds beating on me while I am standing Next to the tank...he has 2 on him and seems content to just let the six stay on me. Next two adds go for me, monk tries being helpful, peels them with SCK, tries to get the into the blades, gets caught himself, he dies, tank gets caught in blades somehow, he dies; adds and Harlan eat my face.
Third attempt; mage dies asap to the blades; fight goes almost exactly like the second apart from that; monk dies trying to help me again, tank gets caught in blades, I manage to save him by going nuts on cooldowns; but he bites it from the boss because I spent so much time trying to save him, I couldn't dispel the boss. Retadin and I die seconds later.
Vote kick comes up for the Mage, reason "idiot"; I vote no, because frankly, the mage was the least of our problems; it fails but the mage leaves anyway; get a new mage.
Fourth attempt, new mage survives first blades, dies to second; adds are eating my face again, I tell them to kill the adds, they ignore it, and by the end I have to pop Tree + NV + Tranq and spam RG on myself to stay alive(at least a dozen adds on me) and the boss dies a moment later.
Rest of the dungeon goes ok, save one near wipe in the room with the coin throwers(I AM NOT A TANK WHEN HEALING DAMMIT! >.<) but we don't because I know my abilities well; clear the place; you'd think I went through all that for the epic ring....but it doesn't even drop.