I think the very first thing I made in Vanilla was a Night Elf Hunter (ugrh, I wish I could erase that memory) but I only got to level 3 before I decided it wasn't for me. After that I made this character. He's not really my main now, I play my Pally more, but this guy still has more days played than probably all my other characters put together.
Edit: The Pally I made mid/late-TBC then quit playing and when I came back mid-WoTLK just kind of got on the Paladin instead of any of my other toons and stayed with it.
Edited by Klutar on 11/11/2012 7:20 PM PST