Background before we begin - I have been playing this game since release. I have been paladin tanking since Burning Crusade. I really enjoyed and remeber naxx 2.0 in wotlk When I could throw my shield and as long as the fight did not require tank movement go afk as auto attacks would keep me top threat.
Now I am a semi serious Raider and our guild is always top 5 on our server, With Mop hitting exp and hit cap are much more important to our active mitigation so that was my priority.
If anything doing that would not be the cause of my low threat.
UNDERSTAND I AM NOT TALKING ABOUT 1 MIN INTO THE FIGHT WHEN I HAVE 70K VENGEANCE
I can be tanking a large group of adds and yes I have great survivability against large groups as my self heals are insane however our offtank which is a monk can come in 20 seconds later do one spin and boom literally pull all the mobs off me. I am not exaggerating.
I appreciate our self heals A LOT however id like to trade that for some more threat so I can do my Job properly. I take tanking very serious and its frustrating when I am supposed to be tanking 2 targets and our monk needs to tank 2 and he ends up getting them all.. Me spamming my taunt is not the answer.
Id appreciate some Feedback if anyone else notices this. I am not super familiar with Warrior or DK threat atm, so if any other tanks have noticed anything please let me know.
**** if other prot paladins are going to say "your wrong dude my threat is awesome" please only do so if you are tanking with a monk tank in the group as well*******