Fixing mage design, mostly frost

90 Night Elf Mage
All the specs have serious issues in PVE. Arcane is a turret that got overnerfed. Fire they have to keep tweaking because of Critical Mass and crit scaling - the preemptive pyro nerf was like a kick in the sack for something that hasn't happened yet. Frost scaling sucks, but they can't buff the stat scaling due to pvp.

I'm not going to really consider Arcane. I hate that spec with the burning fury of a thousand suns, and if it stays to the ground I'm fine with that. Someone who likes it can suggest something for their awful rotation and absolute and total lack of mobility in another thread.

Fire, they've at least acknolwedged that Critical Mass design is a problem, and are considering some suggestions for a better crit buff system.

Here are some suggestions to fix frost's problems with stat scaling and damage:

Mastery is the real problem - it's stacked in pvp for burst damage on player health in a short window, but translates into bad sustained damage only buffing procs and pet damage in pve.

One obvious solution is to split apart the percentages/effects like the Disc mastery change, perhaps add some to it. If mastery also increased say, frost bolt and mage bomb(they already can't balance frost bomb for pve+pvp, adjust it for pvp again as necessary) damage you could adjust the scaling between bolt/bomb/pet damage and the proc/frozen damage to get the stat to scale sustained damage without straight out wrecking people more in a deep freeze.

Another simple idea: consider adding mastery giving a % chance for your frostbolts to treat the target as if they were frozen. This will have negligible pvp impact - frostbolt casts are minimal, and if cast into a deepfreeze they can't count as frozen twice. It would add scaling to all 3 stats in pve though, with the mastery for +chance and +frozen damage, +crit to cap for shatter on the proc, and +haste for more of them.

Lastly, something has to be done about pet freeze. You've taken a janky pve mechanic of using an aoe reticle to generate single target procs in a boss fight, and made it even jankier by having it work only for some adds. Hurry up and add water jet, make it a simple single target damage + 2 fof procs to compare to the freeze shatter + 1 fof charge of freeze, and spare us this mess.
Reply Quote
100 Worgen Mage
With the removal of freeze from the PVE rotation, frost now feels very random. Basically all you do is spam one spell while praying for procs to react to. In that respect it now feels just like fire spec.

The pet is also a complete non-issue now. It's an automatic dot that requires zero attention and can be completely ignored by the mage. It might as well not exist.
Reply Quote
90 Night Elf Mage
The super janky part is that they didn't really remove freeze from the rotation - now you need to know what adds to throw it at, like certain horridon trolls, spirits of loa, emperor's rage, ambers from shaper, the non-cc'd lei shei elemental, etc.

They took "generate a proc on cd using an aoe reticle" and made it "generate proc(s) using an aoe reticle if/when the fight spawns an eligible add" which is even more awkward, and defeats the small point of the change.
Reply Quote

Please report any Code of Conduct violations, including:

Threats of violence. We take these seriously and will alert the proper authorities.

Posts containing personal information about other players. This includes physical addresses, e-mail addresses, phone numbers, and inappropriate photos and/or videos.

Harassing or discriminatory language. This will not be tolerated.

Forums Code of Conduct

Report Post # written by

Explain (256 characters max)