Not sure what's going on here, but the system is broken (it wasn't like this prior to 5.2).
It's boring both ways. It's no fun being slaughtered by a premade, and it's no fun steamrolling over a pug as a premade. If the system is looking at stuff this closely, then it looks like something got twisted around and it's working opposite of what was intended. Otherwise it's some goofy bug that slipped through unnoticed.