I've narrowed my favorites down to Ret and WW, but I'm very divided. Retribution has a fun and easy rotation now, and I've always loved Prot (and holy to a lesser degree) for off specs. Not to mention all that sexy paladin armor. /whistle And of course I'm nostalgic about it since its where I'm started, and its more fun that Wrath that's for sure... >.>
However, with the implementation of the monk, it's a bit difficult for me. The monk has incredible mobility, and while some people complain about its rotation I find it fun and intriguing. The monk also has some fun little tools, like Transcendence and Storm, Earth and Fire. It's new and it's shiny. However, I don't see myself playing MW and BM seems odd.
I'm mostly looking into PvE content, (I'm a total scrub at PvP) and I'm wondering if either class has any significant upsides or downsides to the other I should be aware of, or what any opinions on class choice are otherwise. The Paladin forums have always been full of constructive thinkers, so I'm looking forward to seeing any answers :)