Stopped reading there. If you can't even get this right, I am not going to waste my time reading the rest of your wall of text.
Its dropped massively in subscriptions ever since Cataclysm was released (currently sitting at 10mil down from 12, and thats in 1 year), how is that NOT dying when EVERY single other expansion raised the subscriptions?
You seem to not understand the difference between subscription fluctuation, which happens at the end of EVERY expansion, and a dying game. WoW is over 8 years old, with all the new games coming out and that have come out you can't expect it ti hold at 12 million subs. That is just stupid. But I would say it is also stupid to call a game sitting at over 10 million subs dying. And when MoP releases subs will increase, as they do with every other expansion. Learn to tell the difference. Even if WoW had half of its current subs it would still be a very successful MMO.