Sylvanas-Garrosh Comparison

Story Forum
Q: How are you going to differentiate between what Sylvannas is doing and what Garrosh did?

A: The story's not done. Can't really answer, much left to discover and explore. If I were Sylvanas looking at what Garrosh hath wrought, i'd probably think Garrosh was an amateur.

If I was keeping a running tally above my Sylvanas shrine, because I'm totally not that would be crazy, it would look something like:

Sylvanas:
Lordaeron
Gilneas
Teldrassil

Garrosh:
/crickets
Garrosh would've done all that too if the rest of the Horde had fallen in line as easily as they did for Sylv.
... Theramore? C'mon, you can't be THAT willfully ignorant, right?
11/03/2018 04:38 PMPosted by Skytotem
Garrosh would've done all that too if the rest of the Horde had fallen in line as easily as they did for Sylv.


Maybe he shouldn't alienate his leaders and put whole races under martial law.
11/03/2018 04:40 PMPosted by Deathisfinal
11/03/2018 04:38 PMPosted by Skytotem
Garrosh would've done all that too if the rest of the Horde had fallen in line as easily as they did for Sylv.


Maybe he shouldn't alienate his leaders and put whole races under martial law.


He wouldn't have if the other leaders had pulled their weight right out the door like they did for Sylv's campaign of nelf genocide.
Dang man you mean the obvious villain is being compared to the other obvious villain?
If we were following the same path for Sylvanas that it was for Garrosh it would be something like this

Burning of Teldrassil: Oh no no no no Sylvanas what have you DONE ?! THIS IS NOT HONORABLE!
I WILL STAB YOU BLACK HEART!

Like Vol'jin and Baine did.

But no, instead none said nothing, and they keept pushing the war foward.

So yeah no comparation.
11/03/2018 04:40 PMPosted by Grandblade
... Theramore? C'mon, you can't be THAT willfully ignorant, right?


I was only counting capital cities.

11/03/2018 04:42 PMPosted by Skytotem
11/03/2018 04:40 PMPosted by Deathisfinal
...

Maybe he shouldn't alienate his leaders and put whole races under martial law.


He wouldn't have if the other leaders had pulled their weight right out the door like they did for Sylv's campaign of nelf genocide.


Sylvanas took an entire capital city for Garrosh, by that time he was too busy eating old god hearts to notice.
11/03/2018 04:40 PMPosted by Deathisfinal
11/03/2018 04:38 PMPosted by Skytotem
Garrosh would've done all that too if the rest of the Horde had fallen in line as easily as they did for Sylv.


Maybe he shouldn't alienate his leaders and put whole races under martial law.
Kinda like how Sylvanas is right now Alienating her leaders.
I wanna see this and be like "Ah yeah, We're doing better than ever baybeeeeee! Suck it Blues!" But knowing what happened to Garry, this is just them trying pushing us closer to musical warcheifs. I won't accept it though, I know there's gotta be a better way to handle this. Just messes me up how they tell us it's not gonna be like MoP, but then they pull a monkey's paw and try to make the circumstances worse.
I was only counting capital cities.
Theramore was a capital city.
Are they not even trying anymore?
11/03/2018 04:53 PMPosted by Jellex
Are they not even trying anymore?
ANATHEMA TO THE NOBLE SOUL
11/03/2018 04:52 PMPosted by Grandblade
I was only counting capital cities.
Theramore was a capital city.


11/03/2018 04:36 PMPosted by Deathisfinal
Lordaeron
Also gotta love how destroying her own city is considered an "achievement" even though she failed to kill the Alliance leadership and probably killed as many, if not more, Horde soldiers than she did Alliance.
11/03/2018 04:50 PMPosted by Pyrogar
<span class="truncated">...</span>

Maybe he shouldn't alienate his leaders and put whole races under martial law.
Kinda like how Sylvanas is right now Alienating her leaders.


- She literally just gave Talanji a big ole undead hug
- More allied races has joined under her rule than ever before.
- Lor'themar helped her in Lordaeron
- Gallywix is trying to get her in his hot tub
- Baine is well......Baine

11/03/2018 04:56 PMPosted by Pyrogar
Also gotta love how destroying her own city is considered an "achievement" even though she failed to kill the Alliance leadership and probably killed as many, if not more, Horde soldiers than she did Alliance.


I wasn't talking about Battle for Lordaeron. I was talking about when she wrecked the Burning Legion and other factions during the Third War.
*Raises a hand to protest....then lowers*

Actually DiF is right, I mean I suspect they are right because there aren't really any other leaders present. But the most alienated leader of anyone is Baine, everyone else is just an adviser or something.

Which is probably part of the Horde playerbases disconnect, because who cares about Baine?
...Kinda like how Sylvanas is right now Alienating her leaders.


- She literally just gave Talanji a big ole undead hug
- More allied races has joined under her rule than ever before.
- Lor'themar helped her in Lordaeron
- Gallywix is trying to get her in his hot tub
- Baine is well......Baine


Did you miss Talanji's dialogue about Sylv raising Derek?
- She literally just gave Talanji a big ole undead hug
She kept her onboard because Zandalar is useful. This is also right before Talanji compares her to Zul.
- More allied races has joined under her rule than ever before.
Sylvanas had nothing to do with the addition of the allied races. Baine brought us Highmountain, Liadrin brought us Nightborne, Eitrigg brought us Mag'har, and WE probably bring Zandalari. This coulda happened under any Warchief.
- Lor'themar helped her in Lordaeron
He helped Vol'jin in Orgrimmar, your point?
- Gallywix is trying to get her in his hot tub
Gallywix was trying to get Garrosh in his hot tub too if you read Tides of War.
- Baine is well......Baine
You have a point here.
11/03/2018 04:57 PMPosted by Deathisfinal
I wasn't talking about Battle for Lordaeron. I was talking about when she wrecked the Burning Legion and other factions during the Third War.
I call BS, you woulda said that if you meant this. Garrosh did way more than her in Lordaeron during WC3 in his time as Warchief.
11/03/2018 05:03 PMPosted by Skytotem
...

- She literally just gave Talanji a big ole undead hug
- More allied races has joined under her rule than ever before.
- Lor'themar helped her in Lordaeron
- Gallywix is trying to get her in his hot tub
- Baine is well......Baine


Did you miss Talanji's dialogue about Sylv raising Derek?


Oh that's right, Talanji was there to mumble some stuff about being upset too.

....

I miss Rastakhan.
...

Did you miss Talanji's dialogue about Sylv raising Derek?


Oh that's right, Talanji was there to mumble some stuff about being upset too.

....

I miss Rastakhan.


Well, it is what sparks the search for spirit Vol’jin so there is that.

Join the Conversation

Return to Forum